Fixed #20564 -- Generic relations exclude() regression

The patch for #19385 caused a regression in certain generic relations
.exclude() filters if a subquery was needed. The fix contains a
refactoring to how Query.split_exclude() and Query.trim_start()
interact.

Thanks to Trac alias nferrari for the report.

django/db/models/sql/query.py

@@ -1422,7 +1422,9 @@ class Query(object):
         query.clear_ordering(True)
         # Try to have as simple as possible subquery -> trim leading joins from
         # the subquery.
-        trimmed_joins = query.trim_start(names_with_path)
+        trimmed_prefix, contains_louter = query.trim_start(names_with_path)
+        query.remove_inherited_models()
+
         # Add extra check to make sure the selected field will not be null
         # since we are adding a IN <subquery> clause. This prevents the
         # database from tripping over IN (...,NULL,...) selects and returning
@@ -1431,38 +1433,20 @@ class Query(object):
             alias, col = query.select[0].col
             query.where.add((Constraint(alias, col, query.select[0].field), 'isnull', False), AND)
 
-        # Still make sure that the trimmed parts in the inner query and
-        # trimmed prefix are in sync. So, use the trimmed_joins to make sure
-        # as many path elements are in the prefix as there were trimmed joins.
-        # In addition, convert the path elements back to names so that
-        # add_filter() can handle them.
-        trimmed_prefix = []
-        paths_in_prefix = trimmed_joins
-        for name, path in names_with_path:
-            if paths_in_prefix - len(path) < 0:
-                break
-            trimmed_prefix.append(name)
-            paths_in_prefix -= len(path)
-        join_field = path[paths_in_prefix].join_field
-        # TODO: This should be made properly multicolumn
-        # join aware. It is likely better to not use build_filter
-        # at all, instead construct joins up to the correct point,
-        # then construct the needed equality constraint manually,
-        # or maybe using SubqueryConstraint would work, too.
-        # The foreign_related_fields attribute is right here, we
-        # don't ever split joins for direct case.
-        trimmed_prefix.append(
-            join_field.field.foreign_related_fields[0].name)
-        trimmed_prefix = LOOKUP_SEP.join(trimmed_prefix)
         condition = self.build_filter(
             ('%s__in' % trimmed_prefix, query),
             current_negated=True, branch_negated=True, can_reuse=can_reuse)
-        # Intentionally leave the other alias as blank, if the condition
+        if contains_louter:
-        # refers it, things will break here.
+            or_null_condition = self.build_filter(
-        extra_restriction = join_field.get_extra_restriction(
+                ('%s__isnull' % trimmed_prefix, True),
-            self.where_class, None, [t for t in query.tables if query.alias_refcount[t]][0])
+                current_negated=True, branch_negated=True, can_reuse=can_reuse)
-        if extra_restriction:
+            condition.add(or_null_condition, OR)
-            query.where.add(extra_restriction, 'AND')
+            # Note that the end result will be:
+            # (outercol NOT IN innerq AND outercol IS NOT NULL) OR outercol IS NULL.
+            # This might look crazy but due to how IN works, this seems to be
+            # correct. If the IS NOT NULL check is removed then outercol NOT
+            # IN will return UNKNOWN. If the IS NULL check is removed, then if
+            # outercol IS NULL we will not match the row.
         return condition
 
     def set_empty(self):
@@ -1821,35 +1805,58 @@ class Query(object):
     def trim_start(self, names_with_path):
         """
         Trims joins from the start of the join path. The candidates for trim
-        are the PathInfos in names_with_path structure. Outer joins are not
+        are the PathInfos in names_with_path structure that are m2m joins.
-        eligible for removal. Also sets the select column so the start
-        matches the join.
 
-        This method is mostly useful for generating the subquery joins & col
+        Also sets the select column so the start matches the join.
-        in "WHERE somecol IN (subquery)". This construct is needed by
+
-        split_exclude().
+        This method is meant to be used for generating the subquery joins &
+        cols in split_exclude().
+
+        Returns a lookup usable for doing outerq.filter(lookup=self). Returns
+        also if the joins in the prefix contain a LEFT OUTER join.
         _"""
         all_paths = []
         for _, paths in names_with_path:
             all_paths.extend(paths)
-        direct_join = True
+        contains_louter = False
         for pos, path in enumerate(all_paths):
-            if self.alias_map[self.tables[pos + 1]].join_type == self.LOUTER:
+            if path.m2m:
-                direct_join = False
-                pos -= 1
                 break
+            if self.alias_map[self.tables[pos + 1]].join_type == self.LOUTER:
+                contains_louter = True
             self.unref_alias(self.tables[pos])
-        if path.direct:
+        # The path.join_field is a Rel, lets get the other side's field
-            direct_join = not direct_join
+        join_field = path.join_field.field
-        join_side = 0 if direct_join else 1
+        # Build the filter prefix.
-        select_alias = self.tables[pos + 1]
+        trimmed_prefix = []
-        join_field = path.join_field
+        paths_in_prefix = pos
-        if hasattr(join_field, 'field'):
+        for name, path in names_with_path:
-            join_field = join_field.field
+            if paths_in_prefix - len(path) < 0:
-        select_fields = [r[join_side] for r in join_field.related_fields]
+                break
+            trimmed_prefix.append(name)
+            paths_in_prefix -= len(path)
+        trimmed_prefix.append(
+            join_field.foreign_related_fields[0].name)
+        trimmed_prefix = LOOKUP_SEP.join(trimmed_prefix)
+        # Lets still see if we can trim the first join from the inner query
+        # (that is, self). We can't do this for LEFT JOINs because we would
+        # miss those rows that have nothing on the outer side.
+        if self.alias_map[self.tables[pos + 1]].join_type != self.LOUTER:
+            select_fields = [r[0] for r in join_field.related_fields]
+            select_alias = self.tables[pos + 1]
+            self.unref_alias(self.tables[pos])
+            extra_restriction = join_field.get_extra_restriction(
+                self.where_class, None, self.tables[pos + 1])
+            if extra_restriction:
+                self.where.add(extra_restriction, AND)
+        else:
+            # TODO: It might be possible to trim more joins from the start of the
+            # inner query if it happens to have a longer join chain containing the
+            # values in select_fields. Lets punt this one for now.
+            select_fields = [r[1] for r in join_field.related_fields]
+            select_alias = self.tables[pos]
         self.select = [SelectInfo((select_alias, f.column), f) for f in select_fields]
-        self.remove_inherited_models()
+        return trimmed_prefix, contains_louter
-        return pos
 
     def is_nullable(self, field):
         """

tests/generic_relations_regress/models.py

@@ -131,3 +131,27 @@ class HasLinks(models.Model):
 
 class HasLinkThing(HasLinks):
     pass
+
+class A(models.Model):
+    flag = models.NullBooleanField()
+    content_type = models.ForeignKey(ContentType)
+    object_id = models.PositiveIntegerField()
+    content_object = generic.GenericForeignKey('content_type', 'object_id')
+
+class B(models.Model):
+    a = generic.GenericRelation(A)
+
+    class Meta:
+        ordering = ('id',)
+
+class C(models.Model):
+    b = models.ForeignKey(B)
+
+    class Meta:
+        ordering = ('id',)
+
+class D(models.Model):
+    b = models.ForeignKey(B, null=True)
+
+    class Meta:
+        ordering = ('id',)

tests/generic_relations_regress/tests.py

@@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ from django.test import TestCase, skipIfDBFeature
 from .models import (
     Address, Place, Restaurant, Link, CharLink, TextLink,
     Person, Contact, Note, Organization, OddRelation1, OddRelation2, Company,
-    Developer, Team, Guild, Tag, Board, HasLinkThing)
+    Developer, Team, Guild, Tag, Board, HasLinkThing, A, B, C, D)
 
 
 class GenericRelationTests(TestCase):
@@ -156,3 +156,59 @@ class GenericRelationTests(TestCase):
         self.assertQuerysetEqual(
             HasLinkThing.objects.exclude(links=l1),
             [hs2], lambda x: x)
+
+    def test_ticket_20564(self):
+        b1 = B.objects.create()
+        b2 = B.objects.create()
+        b3 = B.objects.create()
+        c1 = C.objects.create(b=b1)
+        c2 = C.objects.create(b=b2)
+        c3 = C.objects.create(b=b3)
+        A.objects.create(flag=None, content_object=b1)
+        A.objects.create(flag=True, content_object=b2)
+        self.assertQuerysetEqual(
+            C.objects.filter(b__a__flag=None),
+            [c1, c3], lambda x: x
+        )
+        self.assertQuerysetEqual(
+            C.objects.exclude(b__a__flag=None),
+            [c2], lambda x: x
+        )
+
+    def test_ticket_20564_nullable_fk(self):
+        b1 = B.objects.create()
+        b2 = B.objects.create()
+        b3 = B.objects.create()
+        d1 = D.objects.create(b=b1)
+        d2 = D.objects.create(b=b2)
+        d3 = D.objects.create(b=b3)
+        d4 = D.objects.create()
+        A.objects.create(flag=None, content_object=b1)
+        A.objects.create(flag=True, content_object=b1)
+        A.objects.create(flag=True, content_object=b2)
+        self.assertQuerysetEqual(
+            D.objects.exclude(b__a__flag=None),
+            [d2], lambda x: x
+        )
+        self.assertQuerysetEqual(
+            D.objects.filter(b__a__flag=None),
+            [d1, d3, d4], lambda x: x
+        )
+        self.assertQuerysetEqual(
+            B.objects.filter(a__flag=None),
+            [b1, b3], lambda x: x
+        )
+        self.assertQuerysetEqual(
+            B.objects.exclude(a__flag=None),
+            [b2], lambda x: x
+        )
+
+    def test_extra_join_condition(self):
+        # A crude check that content_type_id is taken in account in the
+        # join/subquery condition.
+        self.assertIn("content_type_id", str(B.objects.exclude(a__flag=None).query).lower())
+        # No need for any joins - the join from inner query can be trimmed in
+        # this case (but not in the above case as no a objects at all for given
+        # B would then fail).
+        self.assertNotIn(" join ", str(B.objects.exclude(a__flag=True).query).lower())
+        self.assertIn("content_type_id", str(B.objects.exclude(a__flag=True).query).lower())